Terrorism Legislation

In 2005 the Government attempted to extend the period of detention during which a person can be held without being formally charged with a crime from 14 to 90 days (see below). On losing the vote on that motion, the Government proposed a revision and put a ’28 day’ proposal before the House which it won.

In 2008, the Government sought again to revise this figure upwards asking the Commons to back an extension period of 42 days. The voting results for this motion are given below.

Those that voted ‘aye’ in this division were voting in support of the Government’s plans to extend the period of detention without charge to 42 days.

Counter-Terrorism Bill — Extension of period of detention to 42 days
11 Jun 2008
Division 219

AYES NOES Ainger, Nick Abbott, Ms Diane Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob Afriyie, Adam Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas Ainsworth, Mr. Peter Allen, Mr. Graham Alexander, Danny Anderson, Mr. David Amess, Mr. David Anderson, Janet Ancram, rh Mr. Michael Armstrong, rh Hilary Arbuthnot, rh Mr. James Austin, Mr. Ian Atkinson, Mr. Peter Bailey, Mr. Adrian Bacon, Mr. Richard Baird, Vera Baker, Norman Balls, rh Ed Baldry, Tony Banks, Gordon Barker, Gregory Barlow, Ms Celia Baron, Mr. John Barron, rh Mr. Kevin Barrett, John Battle, rh John Beith, rh Mr. Alan Bayley, Hugh Bellingham, Mr. Henry Beckett, rh Margaret Benyon, Mr. Richard Begg, Miss Anne Beresford, Sir Paul Bell, Sir Stuart Binley, Mr. Brian Benn, rh Hilary Bone, Mr. Peter Benton, Mr. Joe Boswell, Mr. Tim Berry, Roger Bottomley, Peter Betts, Mr. Clive Brady, Mr. Graham Blackman, Liz Brake, Tom Blackman-Woods, Dr. Roberta Brazier, Mr. Julian Blears, rh Hazel Breed, Mr. Colin Blizzard, Mr. Bob Brokenshire, James Blunkett, rh Mr. David Brooke, Annette Borrow, Mr. David S. Browne, Mr. Jeremy Bradshaw, Mr. Ben Browning, Angela Brennan, Kevin Bruce, rh Malcolm Brown, rh Mr. Gordon Burden, Richard Brown, Lyn Burns, Mr. Simon Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas Burrowes, Mr. David Brown, Mr. Russell Burstow, Mr. Paul Browne, rh Des Burt, Alistair Bryant, Chris Burt, Lorely Burgon, Colin Butterfill, Sir John Burnham, rh Andy Cable, Dr. Vincent Butler, Ms Dawn Cameron, rh Mr. David Byers, rh Mr. Stephen Campbell, rh Sir Menzies Byrne, Mr. Liam Carmichael, Mr. Alistair Caborn, rh Mr. Richard Carswell, Mr. Douglas Cairns, David Cash, Mr. William Campbell, Mr. Alan Chope, Mr. Christopher Campbell, Mr. Gregory Clappison, Mr. James Campbell, Mr. Ronnie Clark, Greg Cawsey, Mr. Ian Clark, Ms Katy Challen, Colin Clarke, rh Mr. Kenneth Chapman, Ben Clegg, rh Mr. Nick Chaytor, Mr. David Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey Clapham, Mr. Michael Cohen, Harry Clark, Paul Conway, Derek Clarke, rh Mr. Charles Cook, Frank Clarke, rh Mr. Tom Corbyn, Jeremy Clelland, Mr. David Cormack, Sir Patrick Clwyd, rh Ann Cousins, Jim Coaker, Mr. Vernon Cox, Mr. Geoffrey Coffey, Ann Crabb, Mr. Stephen Connarty, Michael Curry, rh Mr. David Cooper, Rosie Davey, Mr. Edward Cooper, rh Yvette Davies, David T.C. (Monmouth) Crausby, Mr. David Davies, Philip Creagh, Mary Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden) Cruddas, Jon Dismore, Mr. Andrew Cryer, Mrs. Ann Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan Cummings, John Dobson, rh Frank Cunningham, Mr. Jim Dorrell, rh Mr. Stephen Cunningham, Tony Dorries, Mrs. Nadine Curtis-Thomas, Mrs. Claire Drew, Mr. David Darling, rh Mr. Alistair Duddridge, James David, Mr. Wayne Duncan, Alan Davidson, Mr. Ian Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain Davies, Mr. Dai Dunne, Mr. Philip Davies, Mr. Quentin Durkan, Mark Dean, Mrs. Janet Ellwood, Mr. Tobias Denham, rh Mr. John Evans, Mr. Nigel Devine, Mr. Jim Evennett, Mr. David Dhanda, Mr. Parmjit Fabricant, Michael Dobbin, Jim Fallon, Mr. Michael Dodds, Mr. Nigel Farrelly, Paul Donaldson, rh Mr. Jeffrey M. Farron, Tim Donohoe, Mr. Brian H. Featherstone, Lynne Doran, Mr. Frank Field, Mr. Mark Dowd, Jim Fisher, Mark Eagle, Angela Flynn, Paul Eagle, Maria Foster, Mr. Don Efford, Clive Fox, Dr. Liam Ellman, Mrs. Louise Francois, Mr. Mark Engel, Natascha Fraser, Christopher Ennis, Jeff Gale, Mr. Roger Field, rh Mr. Frank Galloway, Mr. George Fitzpatrick, Jim Garnier, Mr. Edward Flello, Mr. Robert Gauke, Mr. David Flint, rh Caroline George, Andrew Follett, Barbara Gerrard, Mr. Neil Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester) Gibb, Mr. Nick Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye) Gibson, Dr. Ian Francis, Dr. Hywel Gidley, Sandra Gapes, Mike Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl Gardiner, Barry Godsiff, Mr. Roger George, rh Mr. Bruce Goldsworthy, Julia Gilroy, Linda Goodman, Mr. Paul Goggins, Paul Goodwill, Mr. Robert Goodman, Helen Gove, Michael Griffith, Nia Gray, Mr. James Griffiths, Nigel Grayling, Chris Gwynne, Andrew Green, Damian Hain, rh Mr. Peter Greening, Justine Hall, Mr. Mike Greenway, Mr. John Hall, Patrick Grieve, Mr. Dominic Hamilton, Mr. David Grogan, Mr. John Hamilton, Mr. Fabian Gummer, rh Mr. John Hanson, rh Mr. David Hague, rh Mr. William Harman, rh Ms Harriet Hammond, Mr. Philip Harris, Mr. Tom Hammond, Stephen Healey, John Hancock, Mr. Mike Henderson, Mr. Doug Hands, Mr. Greg Hendrick, Mr. Mark Harper, Mr. Mark Hepburn, Mr. Stephen Harris, Dr. Evan Heppell, Mr. John Harvey, Nick Hermon, Lady Havard, Mr. Dai Hesford, Stephen Hayes, Mr. John Hewitt, rh Ms Patricia Heald, Mr. Oliver Heyes, David Heath, Mr. David Hill, rh Keith Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David Hillier, Meg Hemming, John Hodge, rh Margaret Hendry, Charles Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon Herbert, Nick Hood, Mr. Jim Hoban, Mr. Mark Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey Hoey, Kate Hope, Phil Hogg, rh Mr. Douglas Howarth, rh Mr. George Hollobone, Mr. Philip Howells, Dr. Kim Holloway, Mr. Adam Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay Holmes, Paul Hughes, rh Beverley Hopkins, Kelvin Humble, Mrs. Joan Horam, Mr. John Hutton, rh Mr. John Horwood, Martin Iddon, Dr. Brian Hosie, Stewart Illsley, Mr. Eric Howard, rh Mr. Michael Ingram, rh Mr. Adam Howarth, David Irranca-Davies, Huw Howarth, Mr. Gerald James, Mrs. Siân C. Hughes, Simon Jenkins, Mr. Brian Huhne, Chris Johnson, rh Alan Hunt, Mr. Jeremy Johnson, Ms Diana R. Hunter, Mark Jones, Helen Hurd, Mr. Nick Jones, Mr. Kevan Jack, rh Mr. Michael Jones, Mr. Martyn Jackson, Glenda Jowell, rh Tessa Jackson, Mr. Stewart Joyce, Mr. Eric Jenkin, Mr. Bernard Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald Jones, Mr. David Keeble, Ms Sally Jones, Lynne Keeley, Barbara Kawczynski, Daniel Keen, Alan Keetch, Mr. Paul Keen, Ann Kennedy, rh Mr. Charles Kelly, rh Ruth Key, Robert Kemp, Mr. Fraser Kilfoyle, Mr. Peter Kennedy, rh Jane Kirkbride, Miss Julie Khan, Mr. Sadiq Knight, rh Mr. Greg Kidney, Mr. David Kramer, Susan Knight, Jim Laing, Mrs. Eleanor Kumar, Dr. Ashok Lait, Mrs. Jacqui Ladyman, Dr. Stephen Lamb, Norman Lammy, Mr. David Lancaster, Mr. Mark Laxton, Mr. Bob Lansley, Mr. Andrew Lazarowicz, Mark Laws, Mr. David Lepper, David Leech, Mr. John Levitt, Tom Leigh, Mr. Edward Lewis, Mr. Ivan Letwin, rh Mr. Oliver Linton, Martin Lewis, Dr. Julian Lloyd, Tony Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian Love, Mr. Andrew Lidington, Mr. David Lucas, Ian Lilley, rh Mr. Peter MacDougall, Mr. John Llwyd, Mr. Elfyn MacShane, rh Mr. Denis Loughton, Tim Mactaggart, Fiona Luff, Peter Mahmood, Mr. Khalid Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew Malik, Mr. Shahid Mackinlay, Andrew Mallaber, Judy Maclean, rh David Mann, John MacNeil, Mr. Angus Marris, Rob Main, Anne Marsden, Mr. Gordon Malins, Mr. Humfrey Martlew, Mr. Eric Maples, Mr. John McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas Marshall-Andrews, Mr. Robert McCafferty, Chris Mates, rh Mr. Michael McCarthy, Kerry Maude, rh Mr. Francis McCarthy-Fry, Sarah May, rh Mrs. Theresa McCartney, rh Mr. Ian McDonnell, Dr. Alasdair McCrea, Dr. William McDonnell, John McDonagh, Siobhain McGrady, Mr. Eddie McFadden, Mr. Pat McIntosh, Miss Anne McFall, rh John McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick McGovern, Mr. Jim Meacher, rh Mr. Michael McGuire, Mrs. Anne Mercer, Patrick McIsaac, Shona Miller, Mrs. Maria McKechin, Ann Milton, Anne McKenna, Rosemary Mitchell, Mr. Andrew McNulty, rh Mr. Tony Moore, Mr. Michael Meale, Mr. Alan Morgan, Julie Merron, Gillian Moss, Mr. Malcolm Michael, rh Alun Mulholland, Greg Milburn, rh Mr. Alan Mullin, Mr. Chris Miliband, rh David Mundell, David Miliband, rh Edward Murrison, Dr. Andrew Miller, Andrew Naysmith, Dr. Doug Mitchell, Mr. Austin Neill, Robert Moffat, Anne Newmark, Mr. Brooks Moffatt, Laura O’Brien, Mr. Stephen Mole, Chris Oaten, Mr. Mark Moon, Mrs. Madeleine Öpik, Lembit Moran, Margaret Osborne, Mr. George Morden, Jessica Ottaway, Richard Morley, rh Mr. Elliot Paice, Mr. James Mountford, Kali Paterson, Mr. Owen Mudie, Mr. George Pelling, Mr. Andrew Munn, Meg Penning, Mike Murphy, Mr. Denis Penrose, John Murphy, Mr. Jim Pickles, Mr. Eric Murphy, rh Mr. Paul Prentice, Mr. Gordon Norris, Dan Price, Adam O’Brien, Mr. Mike Prisk, Mr. Mark Olner, Mr. Bill Pritchard, Mark Osborne, Sandra Pugh, Dr. John Owen, Albert Randall, Mr. John Paisley, rh Rev. Ian Redwood, rh Mr. John Palmer, Dr. Nick Reid, Mr. Alan Pearson, Ian Rennie, Willie Plaskitt, Mr. James Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm Pope, Mr. Greg Riordan, Mrs. Linda Pound, Stephen Robathan, Mr. Andrew Prentice, Bridget Robertson, Angus Prescott, rh Mr. John Robertson, Hugh Primarolo, rh Dawn Robertson, Mr. Laurence Prosser, Gwyn Rogerson, Dan Purchase, Mr. Ken Rosindell, Andrew Purnell, rh James Ruffley, Mr. David Rammell, Bill Russell, Bob Reed, Mr. Andy Salmond, rh Mr. Alex Reed, Mr. Jamie Sanders, Mr. Adrian Reid, rh John Scott, Mr. Lee Robertson, John Selous, Andrew Robinson, Mr. Geoffrey Shapps, Grant Robinson, Mrs. Iris Shepherd, Mr. Richard Robinson, rh Mr. Peter Short, rh Clare Rooney, Mr. Terry Simmonds, Mark Roy, Mr. Frank Simpson, Alan Ruane, Chris Simpson, Mr. Keith Ruddock, Joan Smith, Sir Robert Russell, Christine Soames, Mr. Nicholas Ryan, rh Joan Spelman, Mrs. Caroline Salter, Martin Spicer, Sir Michael Sarwar, Mr. Mohammad Spring, Mr. Richard Seabeck, Alison Stanley, rh Sir John Sharma, Mr. Virendra Steen, Mr. Anthony Shaw, Jonathan Streeter, Mr. Gary Sheerman, Mr. Barry Stuart, Mr. Graham Sheridan, Jim Stunell, Andrew Simon, Mr. Siôn Swayne, Mr. Desmond Simpson, David Swinson, Jo Singh, Mr. Marsha Swire, Mr. Hugo Skinner, Mr. Dennis Syms, Mr. Robert Slaughter, Mr. Andy Tapsell, Sir Peter Smith, rh Mr. Andrew Taylor, David Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough) Taylor, Mr. Ian Smith, Angela E. (Basildon) Taylor, Matthew Smith, Geraldine Taylor, Dr. Richard Smith, rh Jacqui Teather, Sarah Smith, John Thornberry, Emily Snelgrove, Anne Thurso, John Soulsby, Sir Peter Timpson, Mr. Edward Southworth, Helen Tredinnick, David Spellar, rh Mr. John Turner, Mr. Andrew Spink, Bob Tyrie, Mr. Andrew Starkey, Dr. Phyllis Vaizey, Mr. Edward Stewart, Ian Vara, Mr. Shailesh Stoate, Dr. Howard Viggers, Peter Strang, rh Dr. Gavin Villiers, Mrs. Theresa Straw, rh Mr. Jack Walker, Mr. Charles Stringer, Graham Wallace, Mr. Ben Stuart, Ms Gisela Walter, Mr. Robert Sutcliffe, Mr. Gerry Wareing, Mr. Robert N. Tami, Mark Waterson, Mr. Nigel Taylor, Ms Dari Watkinson, Angela Taylor, David Webb, Steve Thomas, Mr. Gareth Weir, Mr. Mike Timms, rh Mr. Stephen Whittingdale, Mr. John Tipping, Paddy Wiggin, Bill Touhig, rh Mr. Don Willetts, Mr. David Trickett, Jon Williams, Hywel Turner, Dr. Desmond Williams, Mark Turner, Mr. Neil Williams, Mr. Roger Twigg, Derek Williams, Stephen Ussher, Kitty Willis, Mr. Phil Vaz, rh Keith Willott, Jenny Walley, Joan Wilshire, Mr. David Waltho, Lynda Wilson, Mr. Rob Watson, Mr. Tom Winnick, Mr. David Watts, Mr. Dave Winterton, Ann Whitehead, Dr. Alan Winterton, Sir Nicholas Wicks, Malcolm Wishart, Pete Widdecombe, rh Miss Ann Wood, Mike Williams, rh Mr. Alan Wright, Jeremy Williams, Mrs. Betty Yeo, Mr. Tim Wills, Mr. Michael Young, rh Sir George Wilson, Phil Younger-Ross, Richard Wilson, Sammy Tellers for the Noes: Winterton, rh Ms Rosie Woodward, rh Mr. Shaun Mr. Crispin Blunt and Woolas, Mr. Phil Paul Rowen Wright, Mr. Anthony Wright, David Wright, Mr. Iain Wright, Dr. Tony Wyatt, Derek Tellers for the Ayes: Steve McCabe and Claire Ward  

 

Terrorism Bill — Extension Of Period Of Detention to 90 Days
9 Nov 2005
Division 84

This motion tabled in 2005 was the Government’s first attempt to revise upwards the time during which an individual could be held in custody without formally being charged with a crime. If accepted, it would have seen the detention period rise from 14 to 90 days.

The motion stated:

‘Amendment proposed: No. 55, in clause 23, page 22, line 19, leave out ‘three months’ and insert ‘ninety days’.’

Those that voted ‘aye’ voted in favour of the Government’s plans to extend the period from 14 – 90 days whilst those voting ‘no’ were voting against the proposed extension.

AYES NOES Ainger, Nick Abbott, Ms Diane Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob Afriyie, Adam Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas Ainsworth, Mr. Peter Allen, Mr. Graham Alexander, Danny Anderson, Mr. David Amess, Mr. David Anderson, Janet Ancram, rh Mr. Michael Armstrong, rh Hilary Arbuthnot, rh Mr. James Atkins, Charlotte Austin, John Austin, Mr. Ian Bacon, Mr. Richard Bailey, Mr. Adrian Baker, Norman Baird, Vera Barker, Gregory Balls, Ed Baron, Mr. John Banks, Gordon Barrett, John Barlow, Ms Celia Beith, rh Mr. Alan Barron, rh Mr. Kevin Bellingham, Mr. Henry Battle, rh John Benyon, Mr. Richard Bayley, Hugh Bercow, John Beckett, rh Margaret Beresford, Sir Paul Begg, Miss Anne Binley, Mr. Brian Bell, Sir Stuart Bone, Mr. Peter Benn, rh Hilary Boswell, Mr. Tim Benton, Mr. Joe Bottomley, Peter Berry, Roger Brady, Mr. Graham Betts, Mr. Clive Brake, Tom Blackman, Liz Brazier, Mr. Julian Blackman-Woods, Dr. Roberta Breed, Mr. Colin Blair, rh Mr. Tony Brokenshire, James Blears, rh Hazel Brooke, Annette Blizzard, Mr. Bob Browne, Mr. Jeremy Blunkett, rh Mr. David Browning, Angela Borrow, Mr. David S. Bruce, Malcolm Bradshaw, Mr. Ben Burden, Richard Brennan, Kevin Burns, Mr. Simon Brown, rh Mr. Gordon Burrowes, Mr. David Brown, Lyn Burstow, Mr. Paul Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas Burt, Alistair Brown, Mr. Russell Burt, Lorely Browne, rh Mr. Des Butterfill, Sir John Bryant, Chris Cable, Dr. Vincent Buck, Ms Karen Cameron, Mr. David Burgon, Colin Campbell, Mr. Gregory Burnham, Andy Campbell, rh Sir Menzies Butler, Ms Dawn Carmichael, Mr. Alistair Byers, rh Mr. Stephen Carswell, Mr. Douglas Byrne, Mr. Liam Cash, Mr. William Caborn, rh Mr. Richard Chope, Mr. Christopher Cairns, David Clapham, Mr. Michael Campbell, Mr. Alan Clappison, Mr. James Campbell, Mr. Ronnie Clark, Greg Challen, Colin Clark, Ms Katy Chapman, Ben Clarke, rh Mr. Kenneth Chaytor, Mr. David Clegg, Mr. Nick Clark, Paul Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey Clarke, rh Mr. Charles Cohen, Harry Clarke, rh Mr. Tom Conway, Derek Clelland, Mr. David Corbyn, Jeremy Clwyd, rh Ann Cormack, Sir Patrick Coaker, Mr. Vernon Cousins, Jim Coffey, Ann Cox, Mr. Geoffrey Connarty, Michael Crabb, Mr. Stephen Cooper, Rosie Cryer, Mrs. Ann Cooper, Yvette Curry, rh Mr. David Crausby, Mr. David Davey, Mr. Edward Creagh, Mary Davies, David T.C. (Monmouth) Cruddas, Jon Davies, Philip Cummings, John Davies, Mr. Quentin Cunningham, Mr. Jim Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden) Cunningham, Tony Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan Curtis-Thomas, Mrs. Claire Dobson, rh Frank Darling, rh Mr. Alistair Dodds, Mr. Nigel David, Mr. Wayne Donaldson, Mr. Jeffrey M. Davidson, Mr. Ian Dorrell, rh Mr. Stephen Dean, Mrs. Janet Dorries, Mrs. Nadine Denham, rh Mr. John Duddridge, James Devine, Mr. Jim Duncan, Mr. Alan Dhanda, Mr. Parmjit Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain Dismore, Mr. Andrew Dunne, Mr. Philip Dobbin, Jim Dunwoody, Mrs. Gwyneth Donohoe, Mr. Brian H. Durkan, Mark Doran, Mr. Frank Ellwood, Mr. Tobias Dowd, Jim Evans, Mr. Nigel Eagle, Angela Evennett, Mr. David Eagle, Maria Fabricant, Michael Efford, Clive Fallon, Mr. Michael Ellman, Mrs. Louise Farron, Tim Engel, Natascha Featherstone, Lynne Ennis, Jeff Field, Mr. Mark Farrelly, Paul Fisher, Mark Field, rh Mr. Frank Flynn, Paul Fitzpatrick, Jim Foster, Mr. Don Flello, Mr. Robert Fox, Dr. Liam Flint, Caroline Francois, Mr. Mark Follett, Barbara Fraser, Mr. Christopher Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester) Gale, Mr. Roger Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye) Galloway, Mr. George Francis, Dr. Hywel Garnier, Mr. Edward Gapes, Mike Gauke, Mr. David Gardiner, Barry George, Andrew George, rh Mr. Bruce Gerrard, Mr. Neil Gilroy, Linda Gibb, Mr. Nick Goggins, Paul Gibson, Dr. Ian Goodman, Helen Gidley, Sandra Griffith, Nia Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl Griffiths, Nigel Godsiff, Mr. Roger Gwynne, Andrew Goldsworthy, Julia Hain, rh Mr. Peter Goodman, Mr. Paul Hall, Mr. Mike Goodwill, Mr. Robert Hall, Patrick Gove, Michael Hamilton, Mr. Fabian Gray, Mr. James Hanson, Mr. David Grayling, Chris Harman, rh Ms Harriet Green, Damian Harris, Mr. Tom Greening, Justine Healey, John Greenway, Mr. John Hendrick, Mr. Mark Grieve, Mr. Dominic Hepburn, Mr. Stephen Grogan, Mr. John Heppell, Mr. John Gummer, rh Mr. John Hermon, Lady Hague, rh Mr. William Hesford, Stephen Hamilton, Mr. David Hewitt, rh Ms Patricia Hammond, Mr. Philip Heyes, David Hammond, Stephen Hill, rh Keith Hancock, Mr. Mike Hillier, Meg Hands, Mr. Greg Hodge, rh Margaret Harper, Mr. Mark Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon Harris, Dr. Evan Hood, Mr. Jimmy Harvey, Nick Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey Hayes, Mr. John Hope, Phil Heald, Mr. Oliver Howarth, rh Mr. George Heath, Mr. David Howells, Dr. Kim Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay Hemming, John Hughes, rh Beverley Henderson, Mr. Doug Humble, Mrs. Joan Hendry, Charles Hutton, rh Mr. John Herbert, Nick Iddon, Dr. Brian Hoban, Mr. Mark Illsley, Mr. Eric Hoey, Kate Ingram, rh Mr. Adam Hogg, rh Mr. Douglas Irranca-Davies, Huw Hollobone, Mr. Philip Jenkins, Mr. Brian Holloway, Mr. Adam Johnson, rh Alan Holmes, Paul Johnson, Ms Diana R. Hopkins, Kelvin Jones, Helen Horam, Mr. John Jones, Mr. Kevan Horwood, Martin Jones, Mr. Martyn Hosie, Stewart Jowell, rh Tessa Howard, rh Mr. Michael Joyce, Mr. Eric Howarth, David Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald Howarth, Mr. Gerald Keeble, Ms Sally Hughes, Simon Keeley, Barbara Huhne, Chris Keen, Alan Hunt, Mr. Jeremy Keen, Ann Hunter, Mark Kelly, rh Ruth Hurd, Mr. Nick Kemp, Mr. Fraser Jack, rh Mr. Michael Kennedy, rh Jane Jackson, Glenda Khabra, Mr. Piara S. Jackson, Mr. Stewart Kidney, Mr. David James, Mrs. Siân C. Knight, Jim Jenkin, Mr. Bernard Kumar, Dr. Ashok Johnson, Mr. Boris Ladyman, Dr. Stephen Jones, Mr. David Lammy, Mr. David Jones, Lynne Laxton, Mr. Bob Kawczynski, Daniel Lepper, David Keetch, Mr. Paul Levitt, Tom Kennedy, rh Mr. Charles Lewis, Mr. Ivan Key, Robert Linton, Martin Khan, Mr. Sadiq Lucas, Ian Kilfoyle, Mr. Peter MacDougall, Mr. John Kirkbride, Miss Julie Mackinlay, Andrew Knight, rh Mr. Greg MacShane, rh Mr. Denis Kramer, Susan Mactaggart, Fiona Laing, Mrs. Eleanor Mahmood, Mr. Khalid Lait, Mrs. Jacqui Malik, Mr. Shahid Lamb, Norman Mallaber, Judy Lancaster, Mr. Mark Mann, John Lansley, Mr. Andrew Marris, Rob Law, Peter Marsden, Mr. Gordon Laws, Mr. David Marshall, Mr. David Lazarowicz, Mark Martlew, Mr. Eric Leech, Mr. John McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas Leigh, Mr. Edward McCabe, Steve Letwin, rh Mr. Oliver McCarthy, Kerry Lewis, Dr. Julian McCarthy-Fry, Sarah Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian McCartney, rh Mr. Ian Lidington, Mr. David McDonagh, Siobhain Lilley, rh Mr. Peter McFadden, Mr. Pat Lloyd, Tony McFall, rh Mr. John Llwyd, Mr. Elfyn McGovern, Mr. Jim Loughton, Tim McGuire, Mrs. Anne Love, Mr. Andrew McIsaac, Shona Luff, Peter McKenna, Rosemary Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew McNulty, Mr. Tony Maclean, rh David Meale, Mr. Alan MacNeil, Mr. Angus Merron, Gillian Main, Anne Michael, rh Alun Malins, Mr. Humfrey Milburn, rh Mr. Alan Maples, Mr. John Miliband, rh Mr. David Marshall-Andrews, Mr. Robert Miliband, Edward Maude, rh Mr. Francis Miller, Andrew May, rh Mrs. Theresa Moffat, Anne McCafferty, Chris Moffatt, Laura McCrea, Dr. William Mole, Chris McDonnell, Dr. Alasdair Moon, Mrs. Madeleine McDonnell, John Moran, Margaret McGrady, Mr. Eddie Morden, Jessica McIntosh, Miss Anne Morley, Mr. Elliot McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick Mountford, Kali Meacher, rh Mr. Michael Munn, Meg Mercer, Patrick Murphy, Mr. Jim Miller, Mrs. Maria Murphy, rh Mr. Paul Milton, Anne Naysmith, Dr. Doug Mitchell, Mr. Andrew Norris, Dan Moore, Mr. Michael O’Brien, Mr. Mike Morgan, Julie O’Hara, Mr. Edward Moss, Mr. Malcolm Olner, Mr. Bill Mudie, Mr. George Osborne, Sandra Mulholland, Greg Owen, Albert Mullin, Mr. Chris Palmer, Dr. Nick Mundell, David Pearson, Ian Murrison, Dr. Andrew Plaskitt, Mr. James Newmark, Mr. Brooks Pope, Mr. Greg O’Brien, Mr. Stephen Pound, Stephen Oaten, Mr. Mark Prentice, Bridget Öpik, Lembit Prescott, rh Mr. John Osborne, Mr. George Primarolo, rh Dawn Ottaway, Richard Prosser, Gwyn Paice, Mr. James Purchase, Mr. Ken Paisley, Rev. Ian Purnell, James Paterson, Mr. Owen Rammell, Bill Pelling, Mr. Andrew Reed, Mr. Andy Penning, Mike Reed, Mr. Jamie Penrose, John Reid, rh John Pickles, Mr. Eric Robertson, John Prentice, Mr. Gordon Rooney, Mr. Terry Price, Adam Roy, Mr. Frank Prisk, Mr. Mark Ruane, Chris Pritchard, Mark Ruddock, Joan Pugh, Dr. John Ryan, Joan Randall, Mr. John Salter, Martin Raynsford, rh Mr. Nick Sarwar, Mr. Mohammad Redwood, rh Mr. John Seabeck, Alison Reid, Mr. Alan Shaw, Jonathan Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm Sheerman, Mr. Barry Riordan, Mrs. Linda Sheridan, Jim Robathan, Mr. Andrew Simon, Mr. Siôn Robertson, Angus Singh, Mr. Marsha Robertson, Hugh Slaughter, Mr. Andrew Robertson, Mr. Laurence Smith, rh Mr. Andrew Robinson, Mrs. Iris Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough) Robinson, Mr. Peter Smith, Angela E. (Basildon) Rogerson, Mr. Dan Smith, Geraldine Rosindell, Andrew Smith, rh Jacqui Rowen, Paul Snelgrove, Anne Ruffley, Mr. David Southworth, Helen Russell, Bob Spellar, rh Mr. John Salmond, Mr. Alex Starkey, Dr. Phyllis Sanders, Mr. Adrian Stewart, Ian Scott, Mr. Lee Stoate, Dr. Howard Selous, Andrew Straw, rh Mr. Jack Shapps, Grant Stringer, Graham Shepherd, Mr. Richard Stuart, Ms Gisela Short, rh Clare Sutcliffe, Mr. Gerry Simmonds, Mark Tami, Mark Simpson, Alan Tapsell, Sir Peter Simpson, David Taylor, Ms Dari Simpson, Mr. Keith Thomas, Mr. Gareth Skinner, Mr. Dennis Timms, Mr. Stephen Smith, Sir Robert Tipping, Paddy Soulsby, Sir Peter Todd, Mr. Mark Spelman, Mrs. Caroline Touhig, Mr. Don Spicer, Sir Michael Turner, Dr. Desmond Spink, Bob Turner, Mr. Neil Spring, Mr. Richard Twigg, Derek Steen, Mr. Anthony Ussher, Kitty Streeter, Mr. Gary Vaz, Keith Stuart, Mr. Graham Vis, Dr. Rudi Stunell, Andrew Walley, Joan Swayne, Mr. Desmond Waltho, Lynda Swinson, Jo Ward, Claire Swire, Mr. Hugo Watson, Mr. Tom Syms, Mr. Robert Whitehead, Dr. Alan Taylor, David Wicks, Malcolm Taylor, Mr. Ian Williams, rh Mr. Alan Taylor, Matthew Williams, Mrs. Betty Taylor, Dr. Richard Wills, Mr. Michael Teather, Sarah Winterton, Ms Rosie Thornberry, Emily Woodward, Mr. Shaun Thurso, John Woolas, Mr. Phil Tredinnick, David Wright, Mr. Anthony Trickett, Jon Wright, David Turner, Mr. Andrew Wright, Mr. Iain Tyrie, Mr. Andrew Wright, Dr. Tony Vaizey, Mr. Edward Wyatt, Derek Vara, Mr. Shailesh Viggers, Peter Tellers for the Ayes: Villiers, Mrs. Theresa Walker, Mr. Charles Mr. Ian Cawsey and Wallace, Mr. Ben Mr. Dave Watts Walter, Mr. Robert Wareing, Mr. Robert N. Waterson, Mr. Nigel Watkinson, Angela Webb, Steve Weir, Mr. Mike Whittingdale, Mr. John Wiggin, Bill Willetts, Mr. David Williams, Hywel Williams, Mark Williams, Mr. Roger Williams, Stephen Willis, Mr. Phil Willott, Jenny Wilshire, Mr. David Wilson, Mr. Rob Wilson, Sammy Winnick, Mr. David Winterton, Ann Winterton, Sir Nicholas Wishart, Pete Wood, Mike Wright, Jeremy Yeo, Mr. Tim Young, rh Sir George Younger-Ross, Richard Tellers for the Noes: Mr. Peter Atkinson and Mr. Crispin Blunt  

Terrorism Bill, Clause 1(2)
Encouragement of Terrorism — “glorifies”
9 Nov 2005
Division 87

In 2005, the Government also attempted to make a crime of the ‘glorification’ of terrorism. The motion placed before the House concerned subsection 2 of Clause 1 of the Terrorism Bill and stated that:

…[S]tatements that are likely to be understood by members of the public as indirectly encouraging… acts of terrorism… include every statement which-
(a)    glorifies the commission or preparation (whether in the past, in the future or generally) of such acts or offences; and
(b)    is a statement from which those members of the public could reasonably be expected to infer that what is being glorified is being glorified as conduct that should be emulated in existing circumstances.

Those that voted ‘aye’ were voting in favour of the plan to make the ‘glorification of terrorism’ a crime whilst those voting ‘no’, were voting against any such proposal.

Muslims argued at the time that the clause on the glorification of terrorism would stifle the legitimate support of those organisations and countries worldwide that were engaged in struggles against occupation and occupying forces.

AYES NOES Afriyie, Adam Abbott, Ms Diane Ainsworth, Mr. Peter Ainger, Nick Alexander, Danny Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob Amess, Mr. David Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas Ancram, rh Mr. Michael Allen, Mr. Graham Arbuthnot, rh Mr. James Anderson, Mr. David Bacon, Mr. Richard Anderson, Janet Baker, Norman Armstrong, rh Hilary Barker, Gregory Atkins, Charlotte Baron, Mr. John Austin, Mr. Ian Barrett, John Bailey, Mr. Adrian Beith, rh Mr. Alan Baird, Vera Bellingham, Mr. Henry Balls, Ed Benyon, Mr. Richard Banks, Gordon Bercow, John Barlow, Ms Celia Beresford, Sir Paul Barron, rh Mr. Kevin Binley, Mr. Brian Battle, rh John Bone, Mr. Peter Bayley, Hugh Boswell, Mr. Tim Begg, Miss Anne Brady, Mr. Graham Bell, Sir Stuart Brake, Tom Benn, rh Hilary Brazier, Mr. Julian Benton, Mr. Joe Breed, Mr. Colin Berry, Roger Brokenshire, James Betts, Mr. Clive Brooke, Annette Blackman, Liz Browne, Mr. Jeremy Blackman-Woods, Dr. Roberta Browning, Angela Blears, rh Hazel Bruce, Malcolm Blizzard, Mr. Bob Burns, Mr. Simon Borrow, Mr. David S. Burrowes, Mr. David Bradshaw, Mr. Ben Burstow, Mr. Paul Brennan, Kevin Burt, Alistair Brown, rh Mr. Gordon Burt, Lorely Brown, Lyn Cable, Dr. Vincent Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas Cameron, Mr. David Brown, Mr. Russell Campbell, Mr. Gregory Browne, rh Mr. Des Campbell, rh Sir Menzies Bryant, Chris Carmichael, Mr. Alistair Buck, Ms Karen Carswell, Mr. Douglas Burgon, Colin Cash, Mr. William Burnham, Andy Chope, Mr. Christopher Butler, Ms Dawn Clappison, Mr. James Byers, rh Mr. Stephen Clark, Greg Byrne, Mr. Liam Clark, Ms Katy Caborn, rh Mr. Richard Clarke, rh Mr. Kenneth Cairns, David Clegg, Mr. Nick Campbell, Mr. Alan Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey Campbell, Mr. Ronnie Conway, Derek Caton, Mr. Martin Corbyn, Jeremy Cawsey, Mr. Ian Cormack, Sir Patrick Challen, Colin Cox, Mr. Geoffrey Chaytor, Mr. David Crabb, Mr. Stephen Clapham, Mr. Michael Curry, rh Mr. David Clark, Paul Davey, Mr. Edward Clarke, rh Mr. Charles Davies, David T.C. (Monmouth) Clarke, rh Mr. Tom Davies, Philip Clelland, Mr. David Davies, Mr. Quentin Clwyd, rh Ann Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden) Coaker, Mr. Vernon Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan Coffey, Ann Dodds, Mr. Nigel Cohen, Harry Donaldson, Mr. Jeffrey M. Connarty, Michael Dorrell, rh Mr. Stephen Cooper, Rosie Dorries, Mrs. Nadine Cooper, Yvette Duddridge, James Crausby, Mr. David Duncan, Mr. Alan Creagh, Mary Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain Cruddas, Jon Dunne, Mr. Philip Cryer, Mrs. Ann Dunwoody, Mrs. Gwyneth Cummings, John Durkan, Mark Cunningham, Mr. Jim Ellwood, Mr. Tobias Cunningham, Tony Evans, Mr. Nigel Curtis-Thomas, Mrs. Claire Evennett, Mr. David Darling, rh Mr. Alistair Fabricant, Michael David, Mr. Wayne Fallon, Mr. Michael Davidson, Mr. Ian Farron, Tim Dean, Mrs. Janet Featherstone, Lynne Denham, rh Mr. John Field, Mr. Mark Devine, Mr. Jim Fisher, Mark Dismore, Mr. Andrew Foster, Mr. Don Dobbin, Jim Fox, Dr. Liam Donohoe, Mr. Brian H. Francois, Mr. Mark Doran, Mr. Frank Fraser, Mr. Christopher Dowd, Jim Gale, Mr. Roger Eagle, Angela Galloway, Mr. George Eagle, Maria Garnier, Mr. Edward Efford, Clive Gauke, Mr. David Ellman, Mrs. Louise George, Andrew Engel, Natascha Gibb, Mr. Nick Ennis, Jeff Gibson, Dr. Ian Farrelly, Paul Gidley, Sandra Field, rh Mr. Frank Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl Fitzpatrick, Jim Goldsworthy, Julia Flello, Mr. Robert Goodman, Mr. Paul Flint, Caroline Goodwill, Mr. Robert Flynn, Paul Gove, Michael Follett, Barbara Gray, Mr. James Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester) Grayling, Chris Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye) Green, Damian Francis, Dr. Hywel Greening, Justine Gardiner, Barry Grieve, Mr. Dominic George, rh Mr. Bruce Gummer, rh Mr. John Gerrard, Mr. Neil Hague, rh Mr. William Gilroy, Linda Hammond, Mr. Philip Godsiff, Mr. Roger Hammond, Stephen Goggins, Paul Hancock, Mr. Mike Goodman, Helen Hands, Mr. Greg Griffith, Nia Harper, Mr. Mark Griffiths, Nigel Harris, Dr. Evan Grogan, Mr. John Harvey, Nick Gwynne, Andrew Hayes, Mr. John Hain, rh Mr. Peter Heald, Mr. Oliver Hall, Mr. Mike Heath, Mr. David Hall, Patrick Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David Hamilton, Mr. David Hemming, John Hamilton, Mr. Fabian Hendry, Charles Hanson, Mr. David Herbert, Nick Harman, rh Ms Harriet Hoey, Kate Harris, Mr. Tom Hollobone, Mr. Philip Healey, John Holloway, Mr. Adam Henderson, Mr. Doug Holmes, Paul Hendrick, Mr. Mark Horam, Mr. John Hepburn, Mr. Stephen Horwood, Martin Heppell, Mr. John Hosie, Stewart Hermon, Lady Howard, rh Mr. Michael Hesford, Stephen Howarth, David Heyes, David Howarth, Mr. Gerald Hill, rh Keith Hughes, Simon Hillier, Meg Huhne, Chris Hodge, rh Margaret Hunt, Mr. Jeremy Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon Hunter, Mark Hood, Mr. Jimmy Hurd, Mr. Nick Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey Jack, rh Mr. Michael Hope, Phil Jackson, Mr. Stewart Howarth, rh Mr. George Jenkin, Mr. Bernard Howells, Dr. Kim Johnson, Mr. Boris Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay Jones, Mr. David Hughes, rh Beverley Jones, Lynne Humble, Mrs. Joan Keetch, Mr. Paul Hutton, rh Mr. John Kennedy, rh Mr. Charles Iddon, Dr. Brian Key, Robert Illsley, Mr. Eric Kirkbride, Miss Julie Irranca-Davies, Huw Knight, rh Mr. Greg Jackson, Glenda Kramer, Susan James, Mrs. Siân C. Laing, Mrs. Eleanor Jenkins, Mr. Brian Lait, Mrs. Jacqui Johnson, rh Alan Lamb, Norman Johnson, Ms Diana R. Lancaster, Mr. Mark Jones, Helen Lansley, Mr. Andrew Jones, Mr. Kevan Law, Peter Jones, Mr. Martyn Laws, Mr. David Jowell, rh Tessa Leech, Mr. John Joyce, Mr. Eric Leigh, Mr. Edward Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald Letwin, rh Mr. Oliver Keeley, Barbara Lewis, Dr. Julian Keen, Alan Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian Keen, Ann Lidington, Mr. David Kelly, rh Ruth Lilley, rh Mr. Peter Kemp, Mr. Fraser Llwyd, Mr. Elfyn Kennedy, rh Jane Loughton, Tim Khabra, Mr. Piara S. Luff, Peter Khan, Mr. Sadiq Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew Kidney, Mr. David Maclean, rh David Knight, Jim MacNeil, Mr. Angus Kumar, Dr. Ashok Main, Anne Ladyman, Dr. Stephen Malins, Mr. Humfrey Lammy, Mr. David Maples, Mr. John Laxton, Mr. Bob Marshall-Andrews, Mr. Robert Lazarowicz, Mark Mates, rh Mr. Michael Lepper, David Maude, rh Mr. Francis Levitt, Tom May, rh Mrs. Theresa Lewis, Mr. Ivan McCrea, Dr. William Linton, Martin McDonnell, Dr. Alasdair Lloyd, Tony McDonnell, John Love, Mr. Andrew McGrady, Mr. Eddie Lucas, Ian McIntosh, Miss Anne MacDougall, Mr. John McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick Mackinlay, Andrew Mercer, Patrick MacShane, rh Mr. Denis Miller, Mrs. Maria Mactaggart, Fiona Milton, Anne Mahmood, Mr. Khalid Mitchell, Mr. Andrew Malik, Mr. Shahid Moore, Mr. Michael Mallaber, Judy Moss, Mr. Malcolm Mann, John Mulholland, Greg Marsden, Mr. Gordon Mundell, David Marshall, Mr. David Murrison, Dr. Andrew Martlew, Mr. Eric Newmark, Mr. Brooks McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas O’Brien, Mr. Stephen McCabe, Steve Öpik, Lembit McCafferty, Chris Osborne, Mr. George McCarthy, Kerry Ottaway, Richard McCarthy-Fry, Sarah Paice, Mr. James McDonagh, Siobhain Paisley, Rev. Ian McFadden, Mr. Pat Paterson, Mr. Owen McGovern, Mr. Jim Pelling, Mr. Andrew McGuire, Mrs. Anne Penning, Mike McIsaac, Shona Penrose, John McKechin, Ann Pickles, Mr. Eric McKenna, Rosemary Price, Adam McNulty, Mr. Tony Prisk, Mr. Mark Meale, Mr. Alan Pritchard, Mark Merron, Gillian Pugh, Dr. John Michael, rh Alun Randall, Mr. John Milburn, rh Mr. Alan Redwood, rh Mr. John Miliband, rh Mr. David Reid, Mr. Alan Miliband, Edward Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm Miller, Andrew Robathan, Mr. Andrew Moffat, Anne Robertson, Angus Moffatt, Laura Robertson, Hugh Mole, Chris Robertson, Mr. Laurence Moon, Mrs. Madeleine Robinson, Mrs. Iris Moran, Margaret Robinson, Mr. Peter Morden, Jessica Rogerson, Mr. Dan Morgan, Julie Rosindell, Andrew Morley, Mr. Elliot Rowen, Paul Mountford, Kali Ruffley, Mr. David Mudie, Mr. George Russell, Bob Mullin, Mr. Chris Salmond, Mr. Alex Munn, Meg Sanders, Mr. Adrian Murphy, Mr. Denis Scott, Mr. Lee Murphy, Mr. Jim Shapps, Grant Murphy, rh Mr. Paul Shepherd, Mr. Richard Naysmith, Dr. Doug Short, rh Clare Norris, Dan Simmonds, Mark O’Brien, Mr. Mike Simpson, Alan O’Hara, Mr. Edward Simpson, David Olner, Mr. Bill Simpson, Mr. Keith Osborne, Sandra Smith, Sir Robert Owen, Albert Spelman, Mrs. Caroline Palmer, Dr. Nick Spicer, Sir Michael Plaskitt, Mr. James Spink, Bob Pope, Mr. Greg Spring, Mr. Richard Pound, Stephen Stanley, rh Sir John Prentice, Bridget Steen, Mr. Anthony Prescott, rh Mr. John Streeter, Mr. Gary Primarolo, rh Dawn Stuart, Mr. Graham Prosser, Gwyn Stunell, Andrew Purchase, Mr. Ken Swayne, Mr. Desmond Purnell, James Swinson, Jo Rammell, Bill Swire, Mr. Hugo Raynsford, rh Mr. Nick Syms, Mr. Robert Reed, Mr. Andy Tapsell, Sir Peter Reed, Mr. Jamie Taylor, Mr. Ian Reid, rh John Taylor, Matthew Robertson, John Taylor, Dr. Richard Robinson, Mr. Geoffrey Teather, Sarah Rooney, Mr. Terry Thurso, John Roy, Mr. Frank Tredinnick, David Ruane, Chris Turner, Mr. Andrew Ruddock, Joan Tyrie, Mr. Andrew Ryan, Joan Vaizey, Mr. Edward Salter, Martin Vara, Mr. Shailesh Seabeck, Alison Viggers, Peter Shaw, Jonathan Villiers, Mrs. Theresa Sheridan, Jim Walker, Mr. Charles Simon, Mr. Siôn Wallace, Mr. Ben Skinner, Mr. Dennis Walter, Mr. Robert Slaughter, Mr. Andrew Wareing, Mr. Robert N. Smith, rh Mr. Andrew Waterson, Mr. Nigel Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough) Watkinson, Angela Smith, Angela E. (Basildon) Webb, Steve Smith, Geraldine Weir, Mr. Mike Smith, rh Jacqui Whittingdale, Mr. John Snelgrove, Anne Wiggin, Bill Soulsby, Sir Peter Willetts, Mr. David Southworth, Helen Williams, Hywel Spellar, rh Mr. John Williams, Mark Starkey, Dr. Phyllis Williams, Mr. Roger Stewart, Ian Williams, Stephen Stoate, Dr. Howard Willis, Mr. Phil Stringer, Graham Willott, Jenny Stuart, Ms Gisela Wilshire, Mr. David Sutcliffe, Mr. Gerry Wilson, Mr. Rob Tami, Mark Wilson, Sammy Taylor, Ms Dari Winterton, Ann Taylor, David Winterton, Sir Nicholas Thomas, Mr. Gareth Wishart, Pete Thornberry, Emily Wright, Jeremy Timms, Mr. Stephen Yeo, Mr. Tim Tipping, Paddy Young, rh Sir George Todd, Mr. Mark Younger-Ross, Richard Touhig, Mr. Don Trickett, Jon Tellers for the Ayes: Truswell, Mr. Paul Turner, Mr. Neil Mr. Crispin Blunt and Twigg, Derek Mr. Peter Atkinson Ussher, Kitty Vaz, Keith Vis, Dr. Rudi Walley, Joan Waltho, Lynda Watson, Mr. Tom Watts, Mr. Dave Whitehead, Dr. Alan Wicks, Malcolm Williams, rh Mr. Alan Williams, Mrs. Betty Wills, Mr. Michael Winnick, Mr. David Winterton, Ms Rosie Woodward, Mr. Shaun Woolas, Mr. Phil Wright, Mr. Anthony Wright, David Wright, Mr. Iain Wright, Dr. Tony Wyatt, Derek Tellers for the Noes: Claire Ward and Mr. Parmjit Dhanda